Find Your Credit Union

The Used Porsche Test-Drive: So Far, So Good

By Lyndon Conrad Bell, January 16th, 2016

You may recall, in part one of this story, we'd set out to learn whether one could truly find happiness behind the wheel of a $15,000 used Porsche. To recap, we'd just acquired the cleanest, most mechanically sound 2005 Porsche Boxster S we could find.

When new, the base price of the Porsche was $53,895. Ten years later, the Boxster had traveled 86,750 miles and the asking-price was $18,988. After negotiating it down to $15,500, we're spending a year learning whether we've found ourselves in sports car nirvana, or blown $15,500 to freefall into a bottomless money pit.

Popular wisdom in these matters says sure, you can get an older Porsche sports car for Toyota Corolla money. However, in the long run, you'll pay as if you'd bought a new Porsche because maintenance costs are so high. Much of this is driven by the fact Porsche parts have a tendency to be priced as if they're crafted from some mystical alloy on a planet hundreds of thousands of light years away. This is exacerbated by the fact the Boxster S practically has to be taken apart to fix anything major, so labor is pricey, too.

Well, just under 3,000 miles in, we're happy to report the Porsche is still running like a champ. The engine winds freely, sounds absolutely glorious in the upper rev range, and shows no signs of its 11-year age whatsoever. Characterized by prescient throttle response, elastic flexibility and exceptional handling, the Porsche Boxster S is considered one of the best sports cars ever conceived and we're loving it.

With that said, there were a few areas in need of attention. A common problem with Porsche convertibles is the holding straps responsible for maintaining the alignment of the top's tension cables will stretch over time. When this happens, the cables don't slip into their guide channels in the roof's frame and protrude when it is deployed. If you've ever seen a Porsche convertible with the top raised and a black cable slightly sticking out, you've seen the problem our Boxster S had. Some $226 later, Armand's Auto Upholstery in Walnut Creek, Calif. installed new holding straps, so that problem is no more.

Additionally, our Boxster's previous owner had scraped the right side of the Porsche against something unyielding. This resulted in scuffs on the passenger door, along with a rather sizable dent in the right rear fender just aft of the vent. For $300, Rudy Hernandez of the Dent Police put his painless dent repair skills into play. When he was done, it was like the dent had never been there. We then polished the Boxster, and happily, the scuffs buffed out. Between Rudy, a $10 can of car polish, and a half-hour of elbow grease, the Porsche's body is once again pristine.

When we bought the Boxster S, we had all its fluids drained and replaced to establish a maintenance baseline. John Maloney's Valhalla Porsche in Lafayette, Calif. took care of this for us for $300. During our initial test drive, we noted the clutch was going to require replacement soon and used it as a bargaining chip to get the price down. But it went out some 2,000 miles later, hitting us with our first major repair bill. Parts and labor (we also replaced the flywheel) came to $2,800 at Valhalla. Yes, that was quite the gulp-inducing invoice, but under our careful stewardship it'll be at least 100,000 miles before the clutch needs attention again.

With the odometer currently reading 89,500 miles, counting the $15,500 purchase price of our 2005 Boxster S, we're into it for a total of $19,176. Given that the Blue Book was just over $19,000 when we found the Porsche; we're still feeling pretty good about the purchase.

Autonomous Driving: Our New Reality


Autonomous Driving: Our New Reality

Autonomous vehicles are on the road and being tested -- and predictions are that we're moving rapidly towards this reality. We contacted Ron Montoya, senior editor at and Jeremy Anwyl, an independent auto industry consultant and analyst by email to get their take on the issues.

Meet Rich Miller: Nissan's Avid Outdoors Truck Man


Meet Rich Miller: Nissan's Avid Outdoors Truck Man

Rich Miller is chief product specialist of Nissan Product Planning for Titan and Armada and is a life-long truck enthusiast. Miller has been with Nissan trucks for over 18 years, and he has an inside view of what a customer wants and needs in the truck market segment.

Mitsubishi Marketing: Looking to Bottle Passion


Mitsubishi Marketing: Looking to Bottle Passion

What is Mitsubishi's new take on automotive marketing? We talked to Francine Harsini to find out.

Off Lease Vehicles

Hundreds of one owner, off-lease cars, trucks & SUVs with low mileage at a great price!

Additional Resources

Most Researched

2020 Honda Accord EX
EX 4dr Sedan
2020 Jeep Cherokee Limited
4x4 Limited 4dr SUV
2019 Audi A4 2.0T quattro Premium
AWD 2.0T quattro Premium 4dr Sedan
2020 Toyota RAV4 Limited
AWD Limited 4dr SUV
2020 Ford F-150 Lariat
4x4 Lariat 4dr SuperCab 8 ft. LB